Agreed. Only way amex plat better is on spends where axis atlas might not give rp like wallet, fuel, rent etc. which are counted in milestone for amex.Even if you spend 4 lakhs per year on Amex Platinum travel card, you will get only one, two or three nights at Marriott with your 40000 bonus + 8000 regular + 2000 referral points.
And not even one night with the 10000 Taj voucher
So it's better you go for Atlas