HDFC SKY or zerodha

[Indrajeet100]

Zerodha any day over HDFC Sky having used both and closed sky in favour of Zerodha. Biggest pain with Sky is they spam you like anything - mail, message, WhatsApp, calls- horrible. I shifted to Zerodha -it is so peaceful now. Secondly their reports are all pain to understand and find. Though ICICI DIRECT is just superb in this, in discount brokers Zerodha is most peace of mind

 

[ccninja]

you people are really helpful. could you share more about SOA. i want to invest in sip max 2-3 mf including parag flexi cap. what you suggest other two/three funds and through amc or mfcentral? also share the link.

i am singing up for ppfas https://selfinvest.ppfas.com/v2/investor/step-1

@its_karan @fradela

 

[ccninja]

Zerodha any day over HDFC Sky having used both and closed sky in favour of Zerodha. Biggest pain with Sky is they spam you like anything - mail, message, WhatsApp, calls- horrible. I shifted to Zerodha -it is so peaceful now. Secondly their reports are all pain to understand and find. Though ICICI DIRECT is just superb in this, in discount brokers Zerodha is most peace of mind

so are you using zerodha or icici direct? i don't do intraday/daily trading. just want to buy and hold few stocks regularly.

 

[kiwi195]

I'd gladly pay zerodha more for the peace of mind and no nonsense platform. I have tried almost every major broker. Closed all of them apart from Zerodha

 

[its_karan]

could you share more about SOA.

As in?

what you suggest other two/three funds and through amc

That depends upon you

• A simple Nifty 50 Direct Index Fund Growth (I prefer UTI and / DSP, UTI because of it lowest Tracking difference and DSP because of its lowest SIP amount(100rs per day))
• Along with Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund Direct Growth is the basic template.

The template can be modified. Cant be judged just by 2 comments.

through amc

Through AMC

Invest Directly with AMC always, then manage/ view thru MF Central

also share the link.

Sure

Post in thread 'Groww, Zerodha or any other demat account for buying stocks for long term.'

Jun 18, 2025

So I have to download the respective AMC apps and register by kyc right?
HDFC guy is going to come tom to help me out though with hdfc mutual funds app

Fund House Registration Links:

• https://www.dspim.com/invest/
• https://investor-web.hdfcfund.com/new-investor/kyc-verification
• https://invest.nipponindiaim.com/#/auth/register?type=signup
• https://www.icicipruamc.com/sign-in/register

Consolidated Portfolio Management Link:

• https://www.mfcentral.com/

---

Bank RMs/Employees will not help you get...

• its_karan

• 

Adding UTI to the above list.

UTI Mutual Fund Invest Online

www.utimf.com

i am singing up for ppfas https://selfinvest.ppfas.com/v2/investor/step-1

Cheers!

 

[Indrajeet100]

so are you using zerodha or icici direct? i don't do intraday/daily trading. just want to buy and hold few stocks regularly.

I use both. ICICI direct is way costlier than zerodha but there is ease of doing it and reports and has been my main account. Zerodha I started using a year back and keep stocks meant for short term holding there.

 

[fradela]

you people are really helpful. could you share more about SOA. i want to invest in sip max 2-3 mf including parag flexi cap. what you suggest other two/three funds and through amc or mfcentral? also share the link.

i am singing up for ppfas https://selfinvest.ppfas.com/v2/investor/step-1

@its_karan @fradela

Stay away from Parag Parik Flexi cap. AUM is too high. It is Large Cap now.

Always stick with Index Funds.

1. Nifty 50 or Sensex (HDFC Index Sensex Direct Plan-Growth)
2. Nifty Next 50 (UTI Nifty Next 50 Index Fund Direct - Growth)
3. Nifty Midcap 150 Index Fund or UTI BSE Low Volatility Index Fund (Index Flexi Cap Fund)

If your investment amount is low, stick with one fund enough.

1. Nifty Large midcap 250 Index Fund (Zerodha Nifty LargeMidcap 250 Index Fund Direct - Growth)

 

[Indrajeet100]

Stay away from Parag Parik Flexi cap. AUM is too high. It is Large Cap now.

Always stick with Index Funds.

1. Nifty 50 or Sensex (HDFC Index Sensex Direct Plan-Growth)
2. Nifty Next 50 (UTI Nifty Next 50 Index Fund Direct - Growth)
3. Nifty Midcap 150 Index Fund or UTI BSE Low Volatility Index Fund (Index Flexi Cap Fund)

If your investment amount is low, stick with one fund enough.

1. Nifty Large midcap 250 Index Fund (Zerodha Nifty LargeMidcap 250 Index Fund Direct - Growth)

I have been wondering this for last 5 years and it still keeps beating my small and midcap portfolio.

 

[Kushagra_]

Hdfc sky mein hi toh zerodha ki kite udegi

 

[ccninja]

@its_karan

1. investing in Axis NIFTY 50 Index Fund, is it good? suggest one mf from axis
2. suggest one mf from hdfc.
3. suggest one mf from icici.

 

[Indrajeet100]

@its_karan

1. investing in Axis NIFTY 50 Index Fund, is it good? suggest one mf from axis
2. suggest one mf from hdfc.
3. suggest one mf from icici.

From ICICI this one for long term-
ICICI Prudential India Opportunities Fund Direct Growth
Other than that PPFAS flexi cap

 

[AkitA]

ICICI Direct has interesting proposition, this is what is being offered by ICICI Direct.
Dear Team,

The M52 proposition is now even more attractive for acquiring the best of customers.

We are introducing a new slab of ₹1 crore fund transfer, where customers will receive *₹30,000 in free brokerage for 6 months upon opening a 3-in-1 account . The fund transfer of ₹1 crore needs to happen from any other bank account to their ICICI Bank account.

Key benefits of opening a 3-in-1 account:

1. Customers can now receive up to ₹55,000 in free brokerage by transferring both cash and stocks to their ICICI Bank account:

- ₹30,000 in free brokerage on ₹1 crore of fund transfer to the ICICI Bank savings account.

- ₹25,000 in free brokerage for ₹1 crore of stock transfer to the ICICI Bank DP.

2. Brokerage of just 7 paise in the cash segment plus up to 3.5% interest on funds in the trading account with a high-value Prime of ₹9,999, where the Prime fee is fully reversed as free brokerage credit for 6 months.

3. Industry-first feature, *eATM*, where customers receive instant credit of up to ₹1 crore upon selling stocks, unlike the typical T+1 working day wait on other brokers.

4. The ability to buy stocks and pay later with MTF, at one of the lowest rates in the market, as low as 9.69%.

5. Access to ICICIdirect's award-winning research with Gladiator stocks delivering an 82% strike rate over the last 5 years.

6. The highest-rated new ICICI Direct mobile app, offering in-depth stock analytics and a rich trading and investment experience.

 

[Moulidharan]

if god forbids, something happens to me then my heir should be able to see all the investments in consolidated manner....Govt of India has 5.79 lakh crore UNCLAIMED...All these intelligent people scattered their investments here and there therefore legal heirs do not know that they are so rich...Now govt will become rich by forfeiting this money

My all investments are under MF utility and mapped against single CAN....So i am sure, my investment will not GO to govt.

But i have received some mail from someone like CAMS where it shows where I invested ,how much I have invested everything from all the brokers i have invested with

 

[ccninja]

1. i need some help. i had few mf of rs 500/1000 with groww and zerodha, which i had sold few years ago now those mf profile seems to have old number and even i updated it via mfcentral, camsonline, otp in Kotak and Tata mf sending to old number. can login in Tata mf via email otp but kotak sending otp on email is not working. where to reach? i recently done the ekyc but it had no edit option for mail and number.


2. i also have 2-3 stock in groww and one mf in groww. i want to close and move to zerodha for stocks. what should i do? just sell and move away?

@Indrajeet100 @its_karan

 

[Indrajeet100]

1. i need some help. i had few mf of rs 500/1000 with groww and zerodha, which i had sold few years ago now those mf profile seems to have old number and even i updated it via mfcentral, camsonline, otp in Kotak and Tata mf sending to old number. can login in Tata mf via email otp but kotak sending otp on email is not working. where to reach? i recently done the ekyc but it had no edit option for mail and number.


2. i also have 2-3 stock in groww and one mf in groww. i want to close and move to zerodha for stocks. what should i do? just sell and move away?

@Indrajeet100 @its_karan

1. You probably have MF in demat format instead of statement. In that case it may automatically take details from demat account. For MF in statement format- you don't need login to any mf sites to transact. Camsonline or mfcentral works fine. There is option to update mobile and email on camsonline - this link

Update Email ID in Mutual Fund Folios | CAMS

Update your email ID in all your folios across CAMS serviced Mutual Funds, and request receipt of all future communication via email

www.camsonline.com

2. It depends how much value. If not substantial- buy and sell is easier. There is one online transfer method through CDSL app but it is very user unfriendly process. There is step by guide on zerodha too. Just google you will find it.

 

[its_karan]

i also have 2-3 stock in groww

Use this but for small quantity, However Indrajeet Ji is right better to sell and reinvest. It depends upon you. i do this transfer if Holding value >50k.

 

[ccninja]

Thanks. i need to do kyc again as it is inactive. the mf details for amc is being taken from demat account and it is already changed in groww yet it is not reflected. camsonline only update mf and not account details of that amc. kinda complicated/

 

[its_karan]

Thanks. i need to do kyc again as it is inactive. the mf details for amc is being taken from demat account and it is already changed in groww yet it is not reflected. camsonline only update mf and not account details of that amc. kinda complicated/

Contact the amc branch office nearby and ask them to coordinate with CAMS, they will happily do it if its a Trusted AMC.

 

[ccninja]

Contact the amc branch office nearby and ask them to coordinate with CAMS, they will happily do it if its a Trusted AMC.

it is Kotak and Tata. in Tata, the account shows old details and use the same but when i click on edit, it shows new one.

when i was new, i invested in multiple mf via groww then sold it within a year, later i moved to zerodha and bought from there, both had different email and number so it is all mixed. i am trying to fix and make them same everywhere.