• Hey there! Welcome to TFC! View fewer ads on the website just by signing up on TF Community.

Best Bank Account for Inward Remittance

  • Thread starter Thread starter WhoU
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 268
  • Views Views 31K
  • Tags Tags
    forex

WhoU

TF Ace
VIP Lounge
I have HDFC salary and BOB savings account. I get RSUs and ESPPs and sell them to get money in my Indian account.

I use inward remittance quite often and HDFC is a pain with calling RM and asking them to get approval for better rates etc.

Do you guys have experience with this? Which bank gives best inward remittance rate with no manual process involved?
 
But heard that , SBI doesn't give FATCA docs .
SBI has been a pain for everyone (old sick folks), better stick to BOB or IOB.
In case of any issues about this product, please contact our International Remittance Centre (IRC) helpline from 10:00 to 17:00 hours (IST) at:
Email: ircresponse.fd@sbi.co.in
  • Tel: +91-33-2288 0242
 
Last edited:
Thanks @IDontThinkSo
Today I realised that the best Bank to offer Forex rates keep changing all the time.
For today, the TT BUY rates on SBI is best and everyone's favourite IOB is worst.
SBI>BOB>IOB
Its not that straight forward and depends on many factors.

What you shared is picking a date and comparing that, which I think would not be a fair comparison.

Average out the best TTBUY by Indian banks and you would find that IOB is quite better in most cases if not all.

Basically, if you have an account in any of the above bank just use it. No need to open a new account for the sake of Forex rates.
Good point about not opening new account.
I too have advised against opening new accounts for single or couple transaction as it is not worth the trouble and does not save much.
However, if the transactions are recurring, that would change this.

It's all about the real-time exchange rate that the banks pick. Even though IOB rates is somehow better but they charge intermediary bank fee by CITI (8$) or other foreign banks, in SBI and BOB they have their own foreign branches that can be used as intermediary.

Google Rate at 02:43 PM IST = 85.97
View attachment 98092

Google Rate at 01:00 PM IST = 85.92
View attachment 98093

Google Rate at 10:45 AM IST = 85.68
View attachment 98097


Banks usually pick rate at a certain threshold time and then set their margin against it.
I have found IOB margins to be around 20p, fluctuating.

Thats also a reason banks can negotiate for the rate, usually private banks for their margin, which usually go around 1Rs less than forex (fluctuating)

Bank will surely charge SWIFT charges which can be lower depending on the intermediary entity.

So all in all, good point about not opening new account unless recurring payments.
 
Even firc they dont give...they dont know what is firc
Thats goes for many bank and branches as forex dealings are not common.
Not all branches and managers are aware of how forex transaction happens. And not many are trained for that purpose.
For example, SBI have special branches for NRI for those purposes.

FIRC has been problematic for many now.
RBI says no FIRC should be given for non-investment related transaction, which bank follows but GST department is another beast.
 
I did not specify US, but wherever there is an IOB intermediary.

How did you confirm for SBI or BoB? With branch or is there a document available in public?
And Nil is for inward remittance, as I assume for outward they will charge regardless of same branch?
IOB has only 4 Swift enabled overseas branch
Colombo
Hong Kong
Singapore
Bangkok

I checked with Branch
Also available here
 
Last edited:
Back
Top